Cynicism vs. Hopeful Skepticism: Argumentation and Science Education in the Light and Colours Debate
Dr. Pierre Boulos
(Arg Studies/CRRAR)
Abstract: At the heart of argumentation is the notion that one can be persuaded to change their epistemic state in the face of argument. That is, typically arguments are associated as a rational means of persuasion relying on logic (the cognitive domain) and the use of rhetoric (the performative domain). Argumentation studies typically encompass four primary theoretical orientations: informal logic, pragma-dialectics, rhetoric, and communicative theories centered on argumentation and critical discourse. Common assertions within these schools of thought identify arguments as propositions, speech acts, or literary constructs. However, drawing from Hample and Brockriede, this paper explores the persuasive notion that "arguments reside not in statements but in people." Just like arguing, teaching aims at having an impact on a learner's epistemic state-learning involves moving from one belief (or lack of belief) to another and maybe newer belief. The outcomes of this process can be described within the cognitive and performative, and affective domains.
His first public insistence that there is to be drawn a sharp distinction between empirically established claims and mere hypotheses occurs in a letter Newton sent to Henry Oldenburg, Secretary of the Society and publisher of its Philosophical Transactions. The letter, dated 6 February 1672, contained Newton’s “New Theory about Light and Colours”. The paper prompted intense debate and lasted six years in print. Most notable were the criticisms of Robert Hooke (1635-1702), Christiaan Huygens (1629-1695), and Ignace Gaston Pardies (1636-1673). The criticisms offered by both Hooke and Huygens centred on what Newton claimed could be concluded from the experiment he called the experimentum crucis. That Newton engaged in a “new way of inquiry” is suggested by the controversies to which his investigations gave rise. The challenges forced Newton to argue his ‘theory’, not hypotheses, and to spell out his Experimental Philosophy. I propose using an argumentation studies approach to explore a scientifically historical event in order to motivate deeper learning and scientific literacy.
November 20, 2026
3:00 p.m.
Windsor Law School
(Faculty Lounge, Room 2200)
All Welcome